Which of these players is the best of the 21st Century?

well Hird was absolutly brilliant for such a long time, Buckley was much the same. as much as Judd, Harvey and Goodes are epic playmakera, I don't think they are in that same league, although Harvey migh just squeeze in. Cousins doesn't even deserve to be on the list but Ablett and Vossy are absolutly amazing to watch, they way they manage to play the perfect game makes them perhaps two of the very best players ever to play for their respectuve clubs. I think based on the conditions of your question it would be a tie between those two, but given Vossy did it for longer and won three cups while he was at it I think puts him that extra inch ahead, that and i'm a Lions fan. And now he's doing a brilliant joba as coach, I think it's gotta be Michael Voss. Lions for the premiership!